Lab Investigation 5 - What is the optimum mole ratio for a reaction?

An investigation of Mole Ratios and Limiting Reactants

Guiding Question

What is the optimum mole ratio for the formation of CO₂ from the reaction of sodium bicarbonate and acetic acid?

Introduction

You have already learned how to balance chemical equations in terms of molecules, for example see the following equations.

Unbalanced:

( 1 )

Mg(s) + O₂(g) → MgO

Balanced:

( 2 )

2 Mg(s) + O₂(g) → 2 MgO

This information can also be interpreted in terms of moles (of molecules).

( 3 )

2 moles of Mg reacts with 1 mole of O2 to produce 2 moles of MgO

Why is this useful? With a balanced equation we can predict the moles of products that a given amount of reactants (in moles) will produce. When moles are used, we are then able to count the number of molecules produced by weighing (in grams). Predicting the amount of product formed or determining the amount of reactants needed for a reaction to occur is called stoichiometry. Most stoichiometry calculations are performed using exact mole ratios of reactants and products. In real life, however, many commercial processes for preparing compounds are carried out using an excess amount of one reactant (and thus a limiting amount of the other). For example, if you mix 2.5 moles of O₂ with 1 mole of C₃H₈, 3 moles of CO₂ will not be produced because there is not enough O₂ added to 'use up' all of the C₃H₈. Once the O₂ is consumed, no more products can be formed, even though some C₃H₈ remains. In this situation, because the amount of O₂ limits the amount of product that can be formed, it is called the limiting reactant or limiting reagent. Therefore, if two reactants are not mixed in the correct mole ratio, the reaction will not go to completion and you will have less product produced and one or more left over reagents.

The Problem

When bicarbonate is mixed with acid, it breaks down into CO₂ and H₂O. Your task is to design and carry out an investigation to determine the optimum mole ratio for the formation of CO₂ by mixing various amounts of sodium bicarbonate and acetic acid. By comparing the amount of carbon dioxide generated when varying amounts of sodium bicarbonate react with a given amount of acetic acid, you should be able to determine the optimum mole ratio of sodium bicarbonate and acetic acid and be able to identify the limiting reactant in the other reactions.

Materials available for use

1.00 M Acetic Acid (HC₂H₃O₂)
Sodium Bicarbonate (NaHCO₃)
Graduated cylinders (1000 mL & 25 mL)
Plastic tray
Electronic balance
Beaker (400 mL)
Side-arm flask w/ tubing
Ring Stands/Rings
Eye droppers

Safety Precautions

Caution:
Handle acetic acid with care.

Caution:
Wear goggles at all times, as pressure is built up in this reaction.

Getting Started

Figure 1: Gas collection set-up

You will need to collect gas by water displacement in order to measure the amount of CO₂ produced after the mixing of acetic acid and sodium bicarbonate in different molar ratios. Once you have determined the amount of sodium bicarbonate you will need to use in each reaction, conduct your experiments. Be sure to keep in mind the goals of the investigation.

1
Determine the optimum mole ratio of sodium bicarbonate and acetic acid.
2
Write the balanced equation based on your data.
3
Identify the limiting reactant in the each of the reactions.

NOTE: It may be helpful to prepare a graph of mL of CO₂ vs. moles of NaHCO₃. Please print the worksheet for this lab. You will need this sheet to record your data.

Interactive Poster Session

Once your group has completed your work, prepare a whiteboard that you can use to share and justify your ideas. See the handout provided for details on this process.

Report

Once you have completed your research, you will need to prepare an investigation report that consists of three sections. Your report should answer these questions in 2 pages or less. This report must be typed and any diagrams, figures, or tables should be embedded into the document. Generally, you need one page for the first two sections and the second page for third section.

Section 1: What concept were you investigating, and how does it relate to the guiding question? What is the optimum mole ratio for the formation of CO₂ from the reaction of sodium bicarbonate and acetic acid? See the introduction for information on reaction stoichiometry, limiting reagents, and mole ratios, and then specifically link these concepts to the guiding question.
Section 2: How did you go about your work and why? This is NOT the details of your procedure, but discussion of the processes. For example, describe the method for collecting gas and why this was necessary to answer the guiding question.
Section 3: What is your argument? You should include the mole and mass calculations table with mL of CO₂ added for each reaction. Discuss the validity and reliability of your data. Make clear your reasoning from mL of CO₂ to mole ratio. Include your graph. This is where you not only present your data, but use the values you obtain as evidence in your reasoning.
Graphing Website: http://nces.ed.gov/nceskids/createagraph/
This third section is where you not only present your data, but also use the values you obtain as evidence in your reasoning. Statements like, "see data table for values" are not acceptable!